web analytics

Tag Archive | "Cindy Holliday"

Man to face trial in dog’s death


Matthew Goldsmith
will go to trial in
Kent County Circuit
Court for killing
his neighbor’s dog,
pictured right.

By Judy Reed

A Spencer Township man’s case has been bound over to Kent County Circuit Court in the shooting death of his neighbor’s Siberian Husky.

Matthew Goldsmith, 43, is facing the felony charge of killing/torturing an animal-third degree.

The decision to proceed to trial was made during a preliminary hearing on Monday in Kent County 63rd District Court.

According to Cindy Holliday, Goldsmith’s neighbor on 19 Mile Rd, she was trying to put her dog, Kita, on a leash, on November 4, when she bolted. She called her friend, Laura Ensley, and they went to search for her. “We were standing right in front of his house calling for her when we heard her whine, and then heard the shot,” she said. “She was literally shot six yards from my driveway.”

Kita, whom Cindy said was an amazing, sweet dog that liked to run, did not survive.

“She didn’t deserve a bullet,” said Cindy. “She deserved a call to animal control and I would’ve dealt with it from there. But not a bullet.” Cindy said the dog had gotten out previously and killed one of her neighbor’s chickens. She said she had apologized to her neighbors and offered to replace one or more of the chickens or pay for them. “But they didn’t want to work anything out,” she said.

On the day of the shooting, Cindy said the neighbor’s chickens were in no danger, and were safe inside the chicken coop. “It is completely fenced in. Kita was not a threat,” she said.

The felony charge is punishable by up to four years in prison and a $5,000 fine. Those convicted can be ordered to perform up to 500 hours of community service; the court may also order psychiatric evaluation. 

Posted in NewsComments Off on Man to face trial in dog’s death

Man charged with killing neighbor’s dog


Cindy Holliday and her dog, Kita.
Courtesy photo.

A Spencer Township man is facing charges in the shooting death of his neighbor’s Siberian Husky.

Matthew Goldsmith. 
Photo from Kent County
Correctional Facility.

Matthew Goldsmith, 43, was arraigned in 63rd District Court on Monday, November 23, on one charge of killing/torturing an animal-third degree.

According to Cindy Holliday, Goldsmith’s neighbor on 19 Mile Rd, she was trying to put her dog, Kita, on a leash, on November 4, when she bolted. She called her friend, Laura Ensley, and they went to search for her. “We were standing right in front of his house calling for her when we heard her whine, and then heard the shot,” she said. “She was literally shot six yards from my driveway.”

Kita, whom Cindy said was an amazing, sweet dog that liked to run, did not survive.

“She didn’t deserve a bullet,” said Cindy. “She deserved a call to animal control and I would’ve dealt with it from there. But not a bullet.”

Cindy said that she had been on good terms with her neighbors before she got the dog. “They had my number. They could’ve called or texted and said, ‘Hey, your dog is over here.’ But they wouldn’t.”

Cindy had Kita for about four months before she was shot. She had gotten her from Laura, who had fostered her for about three weeks. During those four months, Kita had gotten away a few times. 

At one point, she got off her leash and killed one of her neighbor’s chickens. Cindy didn’t know she had gotten off her leash until her neighbor came and told her what had happened. “I apologized and offered to replace one or more chickens, but she didn’t want to work anything out. Instead she just called animal control and said she wanted me to end up in court every time my dog got loose.”

Cindy explained to the Post that she didn’t just open the door and let the dog run. “She was always with me. And if she got away, I was always right nearby, calling and searching for her,” she said. She also took her for a run every day. She said she drove the quad while Kita ran alongside of her.

On the day of the shooting, Cindy said the neighbor’s chickens were in no danger, and were safe inside the chicken coop. “It is completely fenced in. Kita was not a threat,” she said.

When they found Kita, she said they also found Goldsmith with the gun in his hand.

“They feel no remorse,” said Cindy, about her neighbors. “I don’t understand how they think it’s ok to do something like that. I even told them we were working on getting a fence, but they didn’t care.”

Cindy said police have told her that these cases happen often with no resulting charges. “I think it’s fantastic he’s being charged,” she said. “There is no justification for what he did. We need to set an example.”

The felony charge is punishable by up to four years in prison and a $5,000 fine. Those convicted can be ordered to perform up to 500 hours of community service; the court may also order psychiatric evaluation. Goldsmith’s bond was set at $5,000 and he was released on his own personal recognizance. His next scheduled appearance is for probable cause conference on December 7 at 10:00 a.m.

Cindy also filed a PPO against Goldsmith because of the gun and the shooting in close proximity to them and her property.

The Post asked the Kent County Sheriff Office what residents should do if they run into a similar situation.

“The KCSO encourages all residents to contact Kent County Animal Control and their local law enforcement agency if they are dealing with a similar issue; whether they have a dog that is getting loose or if a neighbor’s dog is getting loose and coming onto their property,” said Sgt. Joy Matthews. “Seek help before the situation escalates and gets too severe. Both animal control and law enforcement have resources to assist. If a resident feels that someone has shot their dog unlawfully, we encourage them to report it immediately to Kent County Animal Control and their local law enforcement agency. The two agencies will work together to investigate the complaint to determine if there is legal justification to shoot the dog (i.e. attacking persons, pursuing/worrying/wounding livestock, poultry, etc.). Contact Kent County Animal Control at (616) 632-7300, report non-emergency incidents to the KCSO at (616) 632-6357, or call 9-1-1 for emergencies.”

Posted in NewsComments Off on Man charged with killing neighbor’s dog


advert
Kent County Credit Union
Ray Winnie

Archives

Get Your Copy of The Cedar Springs Post for just $40 a year!